The secrets of Hohle Fels cave
Why aren’t we all Neanderthals? These ancient bird figurines suggest that art was essential to our evolutionary success- by Aeon VideoWatch on Aeon.
Hohle Fels cave is located in southern Germany and has been studied by archaeologists since 1870. The site contains artifacts dating back 43,000 years, including some of the earliest examples of figurative art and musical instruments ever found. These discoveries suggest that Ice Age humans had complex cultures, complete with myths, beliefs, and rituals, much like modern societies. The cave’s excavation leader, Nicholas Conard, highlights these findings in a video produced by Nature and presented by Dan Fox. The cave’s artifacts provide insight into how these early humans may have developed advanced symbolic thinking, which could have given them an evolutionary advantage over other hominins, such as Neanderthals.
One of the most significant recent discoveries at Hohle Fels cave is two small ivory bird figurines. These artifacts are important because they suggest that Ice Age humans had a sophisticated symbolic culture, which may have played a key role in their survival and dominance. Symbolic culture refers to the ability to create and share meanings through art, language, and rituals, rather than just practical tools. Nicholas Conard argues that this cultural complexity could explain why humans thrived while other hominins, like Neanderthals, did not. The figurines are made of ivory, a material that was likely carved using stone tools, demonstrating advanced craftsmanship for the time.
Among the artifacts found at Hohle Fels cave are some of the oldest examples of figurative art, which date back 43,000 years. Figurative art refers to representations of real-world objects, such as animals or humans, rather than abstract shapes. These early artworks include sculptures and engravings, showing that Ice Age humans had the ability to create detailed and meaningful images. Such art is not just decorative; it likely played a role in their cultural and social practices, such as storytelling or rituals. The discovery of these artworks challenges the idea that symbolic thought and creativity emerged only in more recent human history.
Hohle Fels cave is also home to some of the oldest known musical instruments, dating back 43,000 years. These instruments include flutes made from bird bones and mammoth ivory, which were likely used in rituals or communal activities. The discovery of these flutes suggests that music was an important part of Ice Age human culture, possibly used for social bonding or spiritual purposes. The instruments are remarkably well-preserved, allowing researchers to study their construction and even recreate the sounds they may have produced. This finding highlights the advanced cultural practices of early humans.
Nicholas Conard suggests that the symbolic culture uncovered at Hohle Fels cave may have given humans an evolutionary advantage over other hominins, such as Neanderthals. This advantage could stem from the ability to create and share complex ideas, which would have improved communication, cooperation, and innovation within human groups. Symbolic culture allowed humans to develop shared beliefs, rituals, and art, which strengthened social bonds and facilitated collective problem-solving. Over time, these traits may have contributed to the survival and expansion of humans while other hominins declined.

